Get Practice Insider free
Join independent practice owners reading it every week. Enter your email and the next issue lands in your inbox.
No spam. One email a week. We never sell your address.
Issue 2 · Week of June 8, 2026
Your commercial contracts auto-renewed again — the 10-20 codes worth renegotiating
Before you act on any number here: Practice Insider gives general operational guidance on running an independent practice. It is not legal, compliance, tax, or financial advice. Confirm any billing, coding, payer-contract, or insurance step with qualified healthcare counsel, a certified professional coder, or your own advisor before acting on it.
The lead: your evergreen contracts are quietly underpaying you
Most independent practices have never renegotiated a commercial payer contract since the day they signed. Those contracts are 'evergreen' — they auto-renew at the same fee schedule year after year while costs rise, so a rate set in 2019 is still paying you 2019 dollars. You do not need to renegotiate the whole schedule. You need the 10-20 CPT codes that actually drive your revenue.
5-7 codes typically generate 70-80 percent of a practice's commercial revenue — that short list is where a renegotiation actually moves money.
Benchmark those top codes against the current Medicare allowable for your locality. Commercial rates are usually quoted as a percentage of Medicare; healthy independent contracts often sit at 110-150 percent of Medicare for office E/M codes, though it varies widely by specialty, market, and your negotiating position. If your top codes are paying at or below Medicare, that is the gap to raise. Pull a 12-month frequency report from your billing system, sort by total paid, and you have your negotiation list in about 20 minutes.
What to actually ask for
Send the payer's provider relations contact a written request to renegotiate specific codes, with your frequency data and the Medicare benchmark attached. Ask for a defined percentage of the current Medicare fee schedule on your top codes — a concrete number like '130 percent of Medicare on 99213 and 99214' is harder to brush off than 'a rate increase.' Also ask them to strike or shorten the evergreen clause so the rate is revisited on a set schedule. Expect 60-90 days for a response, and expect the first answer to be no on at least some codes; counter with your volume and quality data.
Quick hits
Coding: the 99213-vs-99214 gap you are leaving on the table
A 99214 pays roughly 35-45 dollars more than a 99213 at most commercial rates, and many practices undercode out of audit fear. Since the 2021 E/M rules, you can justify a 99214 on either total time (30-39 minutes on the date of service, documented) or moderate medical decision-making — a stable chronic condition plus a prescription-drug management decision usually clears the MDM bar. If your distribution is 70 percent 99213 and you run 25 of these visits a day, shifting even 5 visits a day to a properly documented 99214 is roughly 40,000-55,000 dollars a year. Audit your own distribution against peers in your specialty before assuming you are coding correctly.
Front desk: real-time eligibility is the cheapest denial you can prevent
Eligibility and registration errors drive a large share of denials — commonly cited at 20-25 percent of all denied claims, and they are among the most preventable. A clean claim costs only a few dollars to process; a worked denial commonly runs 25-40 dollars in staff time to rework and resubmit, and a chunk are never reworked at all. Run real-time eligibility at scheduling and again at check-in, not just monthly batch checks. Confirm active coverage, plan type, copay, and remaining deductible before the patient is roomed. This is the lowest-cost revenue lever a front desk controls.
Malpractice: budget for tail coverage before you ever need it
If you carry a claims-made policy, you owe 'tail' coverage when it ends — and tail commonly costs 1.5-2x your annual mature premium as a one-time bill. It bites at the worst moments: a provider leaving the group, switching carriers, or retiring. On a 12,000-dollar annual premium, that is an 18,000-24,000-dollar surprise at transition. Two defenses: ask whether a new employer or carrier will cover the tail (often negotiable in hiring), or price an occurrence policy, which costs more annually but carries no tail. Decide this before any provider transition, not during one.
Find help renegotiating before the next auto-renewal
Compare medical billing and RCM services on GetPracticeHelp that handle payer-contract benchmarking and fee-schedule analysis, so your top codes get reviewed against current Medicare rates instead of riding an evergreen clause.
Browse billing and RCM services →On the numbers: these figures are general medical-practice-management industry norms — MGMA-style benchmarking, Medicare fee-schedule references, and payer-published timelines — not guarantees. Check every number against your own specialty, payer mix, locality fee schedule, and state rules before acting.